Keyframer should "see" Layers in Multiply blend mode from another Project

[D.T. Nethery]

This feels like a bug.

Here's the problem: I'm attempting to use the KeyFramer FX to composite an image from another .tvpp project into my current .tvpp project. I go to the Keyframer, select my other .tvpp project as the Source , but nothing shows up ... frustration ensues ... spent 20 minutes saving the projects, closing the projects, re-opening , reattempting to composite the layers using the Keyframer ... finally I think to myself: "is it because the layers from the other project are in Multiply Blend mode ?" So then I change them to Color Blend mode and then go back to the new project , and now the layers show up as expected when composited using the KeyFramer. That does not seem like it should be the case . Why can't the Keyframer "see" layers in blend modes other than normal Color mode ?

I would request that this behavior change so that when a project or layer is set as the Source in the Keyframer , it will be brought into the project by the Keyframer exactly as it is visible in the other project , whether it is in Color blend mode or Multiply, or Overlay or what have you. Or if the new layer has to also be set to Multiply then there should be a pop-up to remind the user that the blend mode of the layer must match the blend mode of the Source layer/project .

[Peter Wassink]

This is a very old issue, TVPaint is not treating blendmodes in a WhatYouSeeIsWhatYouGet way.
everything is fine in the project but as soon as you export out of tvpaint or import it into another tvpproject tvpaint doen't deliver.

[Xavier]

Hi, could you please provide a step-by-step scenario to reproduce this ?
Thanks in advance !

[D.T. Nethery]

Hi, could you please provide a step-by-step scenario to reproduce this ?
Thanks in advance !

Sorry , I neglected to respond to this. Here's a simple demonstration of the problem: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jGgvXvYBPbQ



Five layers. Four of the layers are in Multiply Blend Mode. The fifth layer is in normal Color Blend Mode.
Everything looks fine in the original project. Now I want to composite this image in another project.
I open the Keyframer and set the Source to my project with the Multiply blend modes, but only the layer
in Color blend mode shows up. The layers in Multiply blend mode are invisible to the KeyFramer.

[D.T. Nethery]

This is a very old issue, TVPaint is not treating blendmodes in a WhatYouSeeIsWhatYouGet way.
everything is fine in the project , but as soon as you export out of tvpaint or import it into another tvp project tvpaint doen't deliver.

It is also the problem Peter mentions , when you try to export layers with blend modes (such as Multiply) from TVPaint , the blend modes do not show.

Try this: 3 layers , in blend mode Multiply, with 1 layer (line art) in normal Color blend mode. Export to PNG . The resulting PNG image does not have the multiply layers visible , only the line art.

But try the same thing with identical layer structure and blend modes from Photoshop and you will find that the blend modes (with transparency) are visible on the resulting export from PS.

This was exported from Photoshop , with the result that the transparent layers in Multiply blend mode are visible:

blend_mode_export_test_from_photoshop.png (44.09 KiB) Viewed 15687 times

This is the same result exported from TVPaint (where did the Multiply blend mode layers go ?) --

blend_mode_export_test_from_TVPaint.png (32.15 KiB) Viewed 15687 times

.

[D.T. Nethery]

Bump.

I was wondering if the Dev Team could respond about whether this requested improvement may be implemented soon in v 11.7.2 or v12 ?

(or if it's just not possible in the current engine ? )