Pixelated edges around files such as PNGs or TGAs

[mox]

Hi there,

it's an old topic about undesirable pixels around PNGs + alpha that may happens sometimes when loading files outside TVPaint.

In TVP, I'm used to export 32bits PNGs with No PreMultiply and I've been quite lucky so far.
But when I import my files into a tool using a game engine, depending how the colors + alpha are, it's not accurate to say the least.
It looks like every drawing package have its own way for saving PNGs and alpha processing be different...

alpha.png (69.14 KiB) Viewed 4112 times

I tried a lot of things tweaking backgrounds, colors, masks,... Nothing works.

TVP users: what is your workflow to get rid of this edges or at least to soften them?
I know people using SuperPNG but it only works for a well-known tool I don't use :]

TVP Dev: aside FX stack, we don't have RGBA channels, any solutions to prevent this?

[slowtiger]

Oh yes, that is an issue in all programs I use.

My usual workflow is TVP to Moho or FinalCut. In Moho it depends on brightness of top and bottom colour. If I animate white clouds in TVP to put them on a bright blue sky in Moho, I use "no premultiply". Some bright clour on the same colour in Moho: "no premultiply" as well. Anything with a black outline is "premultiply".

[mox]

I tried to export to Premultiply too to spot differences, but it always makes the edges worse like an intentional outline, so NoPremultiply is rather a better choice to export (for me).

To be honest, even if I don't spot differences, I wonder if the choice of the background "None, Color or Check" has impact on alpha when exporting

[Satchiken]

One method you could try is to create and apply an opacity/alpha map.
So one image for your RGB channels, the second image for your A channel.

[mox]

Yes it should work in the case I would be a coder and I'd import two images and "blend" them, but it's out of my hands.
I'm really looking for TVPaint export to be clean...