I do agree with Paul. I am also convinced that only honest but fair critics and discussion will raise the value of this program. This approves the impression of professionals using it. But I also see the danger of discouraging new artists. Maybe the TVPaint Team should consider splitting the wip animation forum part into one for beginners and one for advanced. People who post in advanced should be aware of being compared with the best. Persisting a high level discussion is an essential challenge for any artist in my opinion.I believe that much of the problem stems from the overly protective attitudes of some of the members here who fear that these critiques are dangerous because they might discourage new artists from joining the forums or even from buying the software. Personally I am convinced that the opposite is the case
to Markus: I really enjoyed your film! I do know several animators who are exactly this type! I was laughing a lot! I will send them a link to your film for some fresh arguments against their wives.
I think the voices do fit the film in the overvoice parts. This is why I think the mismatch in the kitchen is caused by a missing kitchen atmosphere in the sound design .
And I do sense the female character a little overacting. A little less maybe would cause more humor. Like the mom of Calvin and Hobbes. Which I was positively reminded at.
The old problem of art, entertainment and budged.Klaus Hoefs wrote: All neat but I was missing personality.ouch.Can't agree, I am an alien from the other planet.Animark wrote:I don't like to spend too much time with one project so I decided for the future
Isn't it a individual and personal decision, which compromises we all have to face hurt most?
Finding the way fitting best with oneself is one thing - but does it also fit with my partner is the other.
Like this little film is telling us about!
Thank you Markus!
vera